Skip to content
Phoenix Coin BuyersCoins, gold and silver

Home / Guides / Selling coins safely

How to sell coins safely

Sell to a buyer who tests and weighs in front of you, shows the spot price they are using and puts every item and price in writing. Walk away from anyone who rushes you, will not explain their number or asks you to leave coins behind.

Coins on a tray under a loupe during a Phoenix appraisal

Red flags

Most coin buyers are honest. A few are not, and the warning signs are easy to spot once you know them.

  • Weighing or testing out of your sight
  • A single number with no breakdown
  • Pressure to decide on the spot
  • A request to leave coins for a few days
  • Offers that change after you agree
  • Traveling buyers who set up for a weekend and leave

Questions to ask

What spot price are you using? What percentage of spot are you paying? Can I see the scale? Will you write down each item and its price? Can I sell some pieces and keep others? An honest buyer will answer every one of them on the spot.

Know the floor

You can work out the metal value of common coins yourself. A dollar in face value of 90 percent silver holds about 0.715 ounces of silver. A one ounce Gold Eagle holds one ounce of gold. If an offer is far below the metal value, ask why.

Get it in writing

A written, itemized offer lets you compare buyers fairly. It also protects you if something is miscounted. If a buyer will not write the offer down, take your coins somewhere else.

Should I mail coins to a buyer?

Only to a well-established buyer you trust, with insurance. A local appointment avoids the risk.

Should I get more than one offer?

It is a good idea for larger sales. A written offer makes comparing easy.

SellFree appraisals

Request a free offer

We call back the same day to set a private appointment.

Add a description (optional)