Skip to content
Phoenix Coin BuyersCoins, gold and silver

Home / What we buy / Old coins and silver dollars

Selling old coins and silver dollars in Phoenix

Albums, rolls, jars and bags of dollars. We pull out the silver, grade the better coins and tell you honestly what is common.

Album of old U.S. coins with a magnifier

Coins we buy

  • Indian Head and wheat cents
  • Buffalo and silver war nickels
  • Mercury and Roosevelt dimes through 1964
  • Washington and Standing Liberty quarters through 1964
  • Walking Liberty, Franklin and Kennedy halves
  • Morgan and Peace silver dollars
  • Proof sets and mint sets
  • Graded coins in PCGS and NGC holders

How old coins are priced

Every coin has a floor. Silver dimes, quarters and halves from 1964 and earlier are 90 percent silver, and Morgan and Peace dollars hold about 0.77 ounces of silver each. Copper and nickel coins have a floor of face value or a little above.

Above the floor, date, mint mark and grade set the price. Carson City dollars, early San Francisco dates and coins in uncirculated condition are worth far more than worn common dates.

Collections that moved to Arizona

Many of the collections we see in the Valley were started somewhere else. A grandfather in Michigan filled blue folders from his paycheck change. A mother in Minnesota bought a proof set every year. When those families retired to Sun City, Mesa or Fountain Hills, the coins came along.

Now the next generation is sorting them out, often from out of state. We go through every folder and set, list the better coins on their own lines and price the silver by weight.

What a typical Valley collection holds

Most collections that reach us in Phoenix were built a little at a time over a working life. Here is what we usually find inside, and roughly how each part sells.

  • Wheat cents by the hundreds: a few cents each, with a handful of better dates
  • Buffalo nickels with worn dates: modest value, more with a full date
  • Silver dimes and quarters pulled from change: priced on silver
  • Walking Liberty and Franklin halves: silver, with premiums for sharp coins
  • A few Morgan or Peace dollars: silver plus a small premium, more for better dates
  • Proof sets from the 1960s and 1970s: silver sets on silver, clad sets near face

Mint marks and why they matter

A mint mark tells you where a coin was struck. D is Denver, S is San Francisco, O is New Orleans and CC is Carson City. Philadelphia coins usually have no mark. One date might be plentiful from Philadelphia and hard to find from Carson City.

Silver dollars from Carson City and New Orleans, wheat cents from San Francisco and Mercury dimes from Denver all include dates that collectors chase. We check every one, so there is no need to sort them yourself.

Silver dollars in the desert

Silver dollars were still common money in parts of the West well into the 1960s. Ranchers, miners and casino workers in Arizona and Nevada handled them every day, and plenty were saved. We see bags and rolls of Morgans that have not been opened in fifty years.

We count every dollar, sort by date and mint mark and grade the ones that might carry a premium. The better coins go on their own lines, and the common ones are priced as a group.

Keeping a few

Many sellers keep a birth year coin, a set a parent finished or a dollar given at a baptism. That is fine. The offer lists every coin or group, so you can choose what to sell. The price on the rest does not change.

How the offer is laid out

The written offer for a coin collection has two parts. The first lists every coin that earned a premium: its date, mint mark, our grade and our price. The second lists the bulk groups, like 90 percent silver by face value, wheat cents by count and silver dollars by count, each with a single price.

That layout makes it easy to see where the money is. Most sellers find that a small number of coins carry most of the collector value, and the silver carries the rest.

Coins from Arizona history

Arizona collections sometimes hold coins and tokens with local roots: trade tokens from mining camps, Territorial era coins, Route 66 souvenirs and Arizona statehood commemoratives. Base metal tokens rarely carry much value, but some mining camp pieces are collected. We look at each and tell you what it is.

GuideHow to sell coins safely

Request a free offer

We call back the same day to set a private appointment.

Add a description (optional)

FAQ

Frequently asked

Are Carson City dollars worth more?

Usually. A CC under the eagle means Carson City, and collectors pay up for those.

Do you buy coins in albums?

Yes. Please leave them in the albums. We look at each coin in place.

Should I clean old coins first?

No. Cleaning lowers their value. Bring them as they are.